tea berry-blue

You went trick or treating as WedgeAntilles.
Jay gave you ALemonDrop.
TheManWithNoName gave you AFishBiscuit.
SteveIrwin gave you TheSugarBowl.
DoctorSmith gave you ASpearmint.
You had a dynamite time until Iago pushed you into a puddle.

What's Your Trick-or-Treat Haul?
Shiver My Timber--A Pirate RPG

ETA Uh, this may be belated, but if anyone can think of objects they want me to include to get as treats, let me know.